All UTV's Polaris Files Complaint for Patent Infringement Against Arctic Cat

[paulk]

saw this and thought id share

http://news.utvguide.net/2013/12/polaris-files-complaint-for-patent.html

 

[dkiewicz]

Popcorn time!!!

 

[dezerteryx]

it sad there going to go after them for that. the money they are going to spend in court they could put into R&D and make a better 50" trail rig if thats truly why they are filling on. don't remember harley suing all the polaris or all the other v-twin copies.

 

[JoeyD23]

As a manufacturer your patents are just as important as the products your making. You must defend and protect them.

No one wants to see this take place but unfortunately it's part of the game.

 

[Candie]

Back in the 3 wheeler days Honda had a patent on equal weight on each wheel. No one else could build a competitive product.

 

[Bunkster]

My guess is there will be a settlement where AC pays Polaris a bunch of money to be able to build the little fella.

 

[Bajaxp]

it sad there going to go after them for that. the money they are going to spend in court they could put into R&D and make a better 50" trail rig if thats truly why they are filling on. don't remember harley suing all the polaris or all the other v-twin copies.

Ummm HD didn't invent the V-twin. Indian (which is owned by Polaris) had a v-twin three years before HD and yet Indian didn't invent the v-twin either. HD thus doesn't have any intellectual property to protect in your example. Polaris does have I.P. to protect, and if you don't actively work to protect your trademarks, patents and copyrights...effectively you lose them. Polaris 'ownes' this patent, which was filed something like seven years ago and was granted just this month due to a the P.T.O. being so far behind. So the question is, if someone takes or uses something that you own it is called what?

 

[dezerteryx]

Ummm HD didn't invent the V-twin. Indian (which is owned by Polaris) had a v-twin three years before HD and yet Indian didn't invent the v-twin either. HD thus doesn't have any intellectual property to protect in your example. Polaris does have I.P. to protect, and if you don't actively work to protect your trademarks, patents and copyrights...effectively you lose them. Polaris 'ownes' this patent, which was filed something like seven years ago and was granted just this month due to a the P.T.O. being so far behind. So the question is, if someone takes or uses something that you own it is called what?

Polaris didnt buy the rights to indian till the last few years and indian hasnt used their own engine since they first went under in the 40's or 50's. The last run used s&s engine which are harley based aftermarket engines. I could understand suing if there were a more specific patent but its like Ferrari suing lamborguino or any other mid engine car builder for that matter. Patent are to protect specific designs, part, or product not a generitc description.

 

[Bajaxp]

Polaris didnt buy the rights to indian till the last few years and indian hasnt used their own engine since they first went under in the 40's or 50's. The last run used s&s engine which are harley based aftermarket engines. I could understand suing if there were a more specific patent but its like Ferrari suing lamborguino or any other mid engine car builder for that matter. Patent are to protect specific designs, part, or product not a generitc description.

My point was that HD doesn't have any rights to exclusivity to the V-twin engine as you alluded to. If you have an issue with the patent you should be upset with the US Patent and Trademark office as they saw the validity to submission and granted the patent accordingly. If you take the time to actually read the filing it is very specific regarding what exactly is being protected.

 

[dezerteryx]

I have read it mulitlple times and looked through all the pics . It is still pretty generic as for a patent. There are some similarities but alot more difference as for what the patent covers. I know im not polaris I don't know what the exact details are just my 2 pesos after reading all of it.