Before I asked this question, I test rode a Wildcat. It seemed like a great machine for the 5 minutes I was in it. However, I couldn't get the dealer to call me back so I could literally hand them a check for the machine. This was a little scary since there aren't many Arctic Cat/Textron dealers around my area should I have any warranty issues. If they couldn't be bothered to take my check on probably one of the easiest sales they could ever hope for, then I could only assume it would be much worse for anything/everything else.
I found a Polaris dealer about the same distance away, went down to see what they had. He had one bare bones RZR 900 Trail left on the showroom floor and didn't expect to get any stock in until at least September. I told him I wanted it and would be back in the morning to pick it up since they were closing and I didn't have a trailer with me. When I got there the next morning, shortly after they opened, the paperwork was already done and I was in and out in less than 20 mins.
I've got 3 weekends worth of rides under my belt now and I love the RZR! It feels every bit as fast as the Wildcat and I've got a little more ground clearance which has come in very handy more than a few times. Hopefully I never have any warranty issues but if I do, I feel confident the Polaris dealer I bought it from will do everything they can to help me out.